Follow us on LinkedInAs a people leader, creating a fair and equitable workplace is one of the most important things you will ever do. It’s the basis of trust, engagement, and long-term retention.
Understanding how to recognize the signs of unfair treatment at work (and knowing how to address them with clarity and compassion) is essential to building a thriving culture.
What is “unfair treatment” at work?
Unfair treatment goes beyond breaches of policy or discrimination laws.
It includes every moment when employees feel undervalued, overlooked, or treated inconsistently. This can come from implicit bias, favoritism, inconsistent communication, or even simple neglect.
While legal compliance is a baseline, fairness is seen as a higher standard because it requires close attention to your employees’ perception and experience.
People who sense unfairness start to disengage and withdraw emotionally, as well as contribute less in the workplace and stop trusting leadership. Over time, the damage compounds, leading to turnover and a negative reputation.
HR professionals shouldn’t wait for formal complaints; instead, you should recognize early signs of unfair treatment before they worsen.
Sam Test Cauthen
10 signs of unfair treatment at work
1. Unequal pay or compensation gaps
When employees doing the same work under similar conditions get noticeably different pay, it’s a strong sign of inequity.
Sometimes justified by tenure or performance, these gaps often persist due to unconscious bias or outdated salary structures.
Regular pay equity audits can reveal discrepancies before they breed resentment.
2. Limited access to growth opportunities
Unfair treatment frequently manifests through unequal access to advancement, mentoring, or learning opportunities.
When certain employees are consistently overlooked for training or promotion, it’s often because decision-makers unconsciously favor people who “fit the mold.”
This deprives talented individuals of growth and signals systemic bias.
3. Micromanagement or excessive criticism
This can take many forms, such as one employee constantly under scrutiny while others are given freedom to operate. Micromanagement maybe a reflection of distrust or bias.
Also, when feedback becomes unbalanced (always negative for some, always positive for others) HR must step in to recalibrate management approaches.
4. Exclusion from meetings or decision-making
Being left out of critical meetings or projects undermines an employee’s visibility and sense of belonging. This exclusion may be subtle but intentional, and you should be on the lookout for it.
When participation is limited to a select few employees, others quickly notice the favoritism, which erodes collaboration and morale.
Teresa Garanhel
5. Uneven workload distribution
Sometimes, managers will overly rely on high-performing employees (as they trust these workers to deliver) while others are underutilized, which creates inequality and burnout.
When those employees are assigned the most demanding or undesirable tasks, it’s natural for them to feel it’s unfair; so, managers need to prioritise a balanced workload allocation.
Regularly review who gets key assignments, who leads projects, and who is left in supporting roles. Fair distribution doesn’t mean everyone does the same thing, but it does mean that everyone gets the same chance to grow and shine.
6. Inconsistent enforcement of rules
Nothing undermines workplace fairness faster than inconsistency. If one employee is reprimanded for being late but another receives no consequence for the same behavior, there’s no consistency in your company; and employees will notice.
After all, they don’t expect perfection, but they do expect consistency.
Unfair enforcement of policies naturally leads to frustration and creates a culture where rules appear negotiable based on who you are, not what you do.
As HR, you should ensure that every manager understands not just the “what” of company policy, but the “why.” Leaders who get the purpose behind rules are more likely to apply them with empathy and fairness.
7. Ignoring or undermining contributions
If employees feel that their ideas are dismissed, interrupted, or attributed to their colleagues, this is a sign of unfair treatment at work.
It’s crucial to recognize and credit people fairly, as overlooking their contributions repeatedly sends the message that their voice doesn’t matter.
8. Behaviors that discriminate
Overt discrimination (whether based on gender, race, age, disability, or any protected category) is the most damaging form of unfair treatment at work.
However, bias also shows up subtly through “harmless jokes,” assumptions about ability, or stereotyping. These behaviors must be addressed straight away.
Sabrinthia Donnelly
9. Retaliation after reporting issues
Many employees remain silent about unfair treatment because they fear retaliation. For example, they worry about backlash, demotion, isolation, or performance scrutiny afterward.
Retaliation is not only unethical but often illegal, and a fair company ensures its employees can report issues without fear of punishment.
10. Lack of transparency in decisions
This refers to decisions about promotions, raises, or restructuring being made behind closed doors with little explanation. If this happens, employees might assume bias is involved.
After all, it’s easy to fill gaps with assumptions when you have no other information.
It’s vital you have transparent communication about your criteria and reasoning, since this helps to maintain faith in leadership and your processes.
Of course, this doesn't mean sharing every single detail. It’s about sharing enough to demonstrate integrity. And employees don’t have to agree with every outcome, but they must be able to understand it.
Recognizing these ten signs allows HR leaders to spot potential cultural issues before they become systemic, as fairness begins with awareness.
Listen to what isn’t being said
Employees don’t always come forward to say, “I’m being treated unfairly.” Instead, they show it through behavior.
You’ll notice absenteeism creeping up, enthusiasm fading, or productivity quietly dipping. These subtle cues are often the first signs of deeper discontent.
Also, pay attention if some employees never contribute or seem hesitant to share ideas; it may mean they don’t feel safe to contribute, not that they’re disinterested.
To uncover what’s really happening, leaders must make it safe to speak up. For example, ensure you have:
- Regular check-ins
- Confidential pulse surveys
- Open conversations beyond the annual review
- Skip-level meetings
Listening also means acting. When people share feedback and nothing changes, trust rightfully goes away. The key is to close the loop, to show employees that their voices lead to action.
Daniel Dickson-Hope
Manage bias in leadership
Bias isn’t always malicious. Managers often make decisions through the lens of their own experiences and comfort zones, which is why favoritism or exclusion happens even in well-intentioned environments.
As HR professionals, part of your role is to help leaders recognize these blind spots and manage them consciously. For instance:
- Managers may favor employees they interact with more frequently (proximity bias).
- Others may reward those who share similar backgrounds, communication styles, or personalities (affinity bias).
- And others might form lasting impressions from one strong or weak performance moment (halo or horns effect).
To mitigate this, leaders should be trained to make decisions based on objective criteria.
It’s important to have regular calibration meetings, where performance ratings and promotion recommendations are reviewed collectively to help maintain balance.
And, when patterns of favoritism emerge, HR must step in to coach and correct, not just to protect the company, but to preserve the trust of its employees as well.
Use data to spot inequality
Data exposes patterns that human perception might miss.
Metrics such as promotion rates, pay progression, performance ratings, and engagement scores (especially when segmented by gender, ethnicity, age, or department) can reveal systemic unfairness.
But this isn’t enough. You need to pair data with context, because while a low promotion rate in one group could indicate bias, it might also reflect a lack of development opportunities.
That’s where qualitative feedback (focus groups, stay interviews, and open dialogue) complements your data.
Connie White
Build accountability
You must train managers on inclusive leadership, feedback delivery, and conflict resolution. However, leaders who repeatedly display bias or disregard fairness principles should face real consequences, not quiet coaching alone.
You can build fairness metrics into managers’ performance reviews, which could include how well they treat and develop their people. This sends a clear message that fairness isn’t optional.
Equally, why not celebrate managers who champion equality and equity? This will reinforce positive behavior.
Respond to complaints with empathy (and integrity)
The way you handle a complaint determines whether employees continue to trust you or the system.
If you want to quickly destroy trust, then dismissing or minimizing concerns about unfair treatment is one of the quickest ways to do it.
When an employee comes forward, you have the responsibility to listen without defensiveness. Let people speak and acknowledge their experience.
If you have to investigate, then be prompt, impartial, and document everything well, since your conclusions should be supported by evidence.
Once the issue is resolved, communicate the outcome as transparently as possible while respecting people's confidentiality.
Employees need to feel that their concerns were taken seriously, even if the result wasn’t what they hoped for.
TL;DR
Recognizing the signs of unfair treatment at work and addressing them swiftly is crucial for a healthy workplace.
Fairness leads to engagement, innovation, and loyalty, so it helps both employees and your company.
Don’t wait for issues to escalate but actively create an environment where fairness and equity is embedded into processes, decisions, and interactions.
Get yourself a (free) Insider membership for exclusive content to help you thrive in your role, from customizable templates to keynotes from people leaders hailing from global orgs.
People Alliance
